• Search
  • Lost Password?
Sharing our love for authors, and the stories they are inspired to tell.

Girl Most Likely
by Max Allan Collins

Tea, flowers and an open book on a table in the garden - Used to feature my book reviews

GIRL MOST LIKELY (Police Chief Krista Larsen book #1) 

Cover Image Of The Book 'Girl Most Likely' By Author Max Allan CollinsIn a small Midwest town, twenty-eight-year-old Krista Larson has made her mark as the youngest female police chief in the country. She’s learned from the best: her father, Keith, a decorated former detective. But as accustomed as they are to the relative quiet of their idyllic tourist town, things quickly turn with Krista’s ten-year high school reunion.

With the out-of-towners holed up in a lakefront lodge, it doesn’t take long to stir up old grudges and resentments. Now a successful TV host, Astrid Lund, voted the “Girl Most Likely to Succeed”—and then some—is back in town. Her reputation as a dogged reporter has made the stunning blonde famous. Her reputation among her former classmates and rivals has made her infamous.

Astrid’s list of enemies is a long one. And as the reunion begins, so does a triple murder investigation.

Krista and her father are following leads and opening long-locked doors from their hometown to the Florida suburbs to Chicago’s underworld. They just never imagined what would be revealed: the secrets and scandals of Krista’s own past.

Cover Image Of The Book 'Girl Most Likely' By Author Max Allan Collins


Alternative Image Of Author Max Allan CollinsA frequent Mystery Writers of America “Edgar” nominee in both fiction and non-fiction categories, Max has earned an unprecedented number of Private Eye Writers of America “Shamus” nominations, winning for his Nathan Heller novels, True Detective (1983) and Stolen Away (1991) and receiving the PWA life achievement award, the Eye, in 2007.

His graphic novel Road to Perdition (1998) is the basis of the Academy Award-winning 2002 film starring Tom Hanks, Paul Newman and Daniel Craig, directed by Sam Mendes.
Max’s movie novels include Saving Private Ryan, Air Force One, and American Gangster, whilst as an independent filmmaker in the midwest, he has written and directed five features and two documentaries.

His many comics credits include CSI: Crime Scene Investigation, based on the hit TV series, for which he has also written video games, jigsaw puzzles, and ten novels that have sold millions of copies worldwide.

Max’s hit one-man show, Eliot Ness: An Untouchable Life, was nominated for an Edgar for Best Play of 2004 by the Mystery Writers of America; whilst his many other credits include. film criticism, short fiction, songwriting, trading-card sets, and a regular column in Asian Cult Cinema magazine.

His non-fiction work has received many honors, whilst as a musician (lead singer and keyboard), he has performed and recorded with his band Crusin’ since 1974.
Max, who also writes as Patrick Culhane, lives in Muscatine, Iowa, with his wife, writer Barbara Collins. They have collaborated on several novels and numerous short stories, and are currently writing the successful “Trash ‘n’ Treasures” mysteries. Their son Nathan translates Japanese into English with a number of novels and video games among his credits.

Check out all the latest news at Max’s website

Follow Max on Twitter

Connect with Max on facebook

Cover Image Of The Book 'Girl Most Likely' By Author Max Allan Collins


“The two girls would be there, of this much you are certain. Two women, actually – “girls” ten years ago, but women now. Judging by their photos on Facebook, both are still quite lovely. Neither is married, interestingly. Well, married to their careers maybe. And if they both attend – and social media chatter assures you they will – and see you, and start talking … what could you do? Stay home, you suppose. But even in your absence they might talk. And if they talk, and that talk spreads, what would become of your career?”

Cover Image Of The Book 'Girl Most Likely' By Author Max Allan Collins


“You are not anxious to do this. Well, that’s not exactly right. You are anxious, in the sense that anxiety is a low fluctuating hum beneath your surface calm. You are prepared to do this only to protect yourself. You really have no wish to hurt her. The memories with this one are too fresh. Too sweet. Too vivid. But you will probably have to do it.”

Cover Image Of The Book 'Girl Most Likely' By Author Max Allan Collins


“It’s never too late for revenge”

From what appears to be a slightly different approach to the author’s usual style of writing, this was a well constructed, thoughtfully researched, police procedural / murder mystery, which packed a punch in the scenes when it needed to ratchet up the tension, throwing in just enough red herrings to maintain the intrigue and kept me guessing right to the end – and, I have to admit, still quite a way from me getting it right!

The core plot was very relevant and on trend with current news features, highlighting with great clarity and insight, the enormous and potentially personal risks which whistleblowers are prepared to take, to ‘out’ their personal nemeses, often with disastrous consequences for themselves and others. Although it is a debatable point as to whether there would have been anyone stepping up to point the finger, if the murderer hadn’t panicked about the concept of a reunion and pre-empted a hypothetical situation – who knows!

Whilst I was happy that Krista was keeping her head above water during the investigation, I wasn’t completely comfortable with her role as Chief of Police, feeling that she wasn’t quite strong enough in personality, or experienced and confident enough in her new position to achieve her full potential. I am hoping that her role will grow in stature and independence as the series progresses and that Keith will take slightly more of back seat, perhaps as more of an advisor than a partner, although they do play off one another well, so there is no way the partnership should be ended completely, anytime soon.

I don’t think that Krista’s first major investigation was helped by the fact that the victims, just about all the suspects and indeed, the murderer, were known to her personally, and had been since childhood. Also, as the investigation unfolded, it became clear that Krista herself was involved in the complex events of the past, which had helped to bring about these current tragic developments.

Although she took great pains not to allow that to colour her judgement, to stay focused and professional, it took Keith’s experience and wisdom to start separating the wood from the trees, with the help of those few former friends and colleagues of the perpetrator, who realizing that something had been amiss for some time, were finally made to feel guilty enough to voice their doubts, even if it was only so that they were able to be eliminated as suspects themselves! I would have quite liked a little more detailed account of the accusers suspicions, although that didn’t really detract from the storyline, or the pace events moved at.

On the whole, Max managed to create quite a disparate bunch of suspects, none of which for me, were particularly likeable, which is probably what made the revelation of the actual perpetrator so difficult for me to work out. However, I did really like the idea that I got to ‘know’ the killer and a little of what they were thinking, as Max very cleverly had the book’s chapters switch back and forth between the first and third person, so that we read about the murders as they happened and from the killer’s point of view.

From a purely personal perspective, after a story so choc full of lavish descriptions, including the breath-taking end game, which might have benefitted from a little more time and attention to detail, I would have liked to have heard more about the killer’s motives for their original crimes, alongside them describing how they were committing their present day murders, an area which was left a little vague.  There were also one or two seemingly unrelated outside events which were thrown into the mix, mostly concerning Krista’s father, which were also left as rather ‘unfinished business’ – I wonder if this was a deliberate omission, so that they were left as possible tie-ins to any future storylines?

Following on from earlier posts about the bookwhere I indicated that Max planned to write a further story featuring the father / daughter team, which would be a prequel to Girl Most Likely, I am now pleased to announce that the next book will form part of an extended series, with the prequel being put on hold for a while.

A Twitter follower posed the question as to whether we ever read the acknowledgements at the end of a book, or if we closed the cover as soon as the story was done with?

Well! I have to admit that I rarely bother with the acknowledgement pages, unless I have a few more minutes reading time available, but not quite enough time to begin a new book.

However, this was one such occasion and I was pleased to discover that the City of Galena, Illinois, does in fact have a female Police Chief, who having worked her way up through the ranks, was more than amenable to answering Max’s questions about the local area and policing procedure, adding credence to the storyline and illustrating the research and attention to detail by the author.

I was even more pleased to have a few moments left to research a little about the City, which is named after a mineral mined in the area, was the home of Ulysses S. Grant and several other Civil War Generals and is today, a popular tourist destination in the region.

Alternative Image Of Author Max Allan Collins

This book was a complimentary download, provided by Little Bird Publicity and facilitated by NetGalley. However, any thoughts or comments are my own personal opinion and I am in no way being monetarily compensated for this, or any other article relating to the book.

From preference, I do not agree with ‘rating’ a book, as the overall reading experience is so much a matter of personal taste, which will vary from reader to reader. However some review sites do require a rating value, so when posted to such a site, Girl Most Likely will attract a 4 out of 5 star rating.


Written by

I can’t remember a time, even as a child, when I haven’t been passionate about books and reading.
I began blogging, when I realised just how many other people out there shared my passion for the written word and I have been continually amazed at the wealth of books that are available and the amount of great new friends I have made, from literally 'The Four Corners Of The World'.

View all articles
Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • As always, a detailed and thoughtful review from you, Yvonne. You always make the books you read sound interesting and tempting but are honest when the book wasn’t quite what you expected. So pleased you enjoyed this one. Small town Illinois is quite an unusual setting, I see Galena is up near the Wisconsin border and is situated on the Mississippi. Fascinating!

    • Hi Cath,

      I will quite often check out place names in a book, just to see if they are real or fictional. Increasingly, I find that authors are choosing to feature genuine places and venues, which I suppose has its ‘fors and againsts’ if you actually live in one of those locations.

      I do always try to aim for objectivity in my reviews, rather than subjectivity, however at the end of the day, a review is still only a personal opinion and authors do need to take that into account and be prepared for some criticism from their readers, and I’m not sure that is always the case.

      To be honest though, it does take an awful lot to make me too unhappy with a book, as I enjoy just about everything I read. Most storylines are so diverse and interesting – and let’s not forget, that with me personally not reading much non-fiction, everything I read is pure escapism and entertainment value anyway!

      ‘Girl Most Likely’ may not have been one of the most in depth and complicated storylines I have ever read, but it was definitely entertaining and enjoyable.

      Thanks for taking the time to make such an interesting comment and for your kind words, I appreciate both 🙂

  • I enjoyed your review, Yvonne. I grew up in the tri-state area that is the setting of the book which added a lot to my reading. As you know mysteries are not my usual reading fare but when I saw Galena (where I’ve visited), Dubuque (where I was born) and Prairie du Chien (where I grew up) figured into the story I knew I had to read it.

    • Hi Mary,

      I can relate to your comments, as I too, will generally tend to support authors who either live in, or originate from an area which is local to me, or write about particular sections or locations of the country, with which I have an affinity.

      I don’t know if you managed to catch the recent interview I published with the author of ‘Girl Most Likely’, Max Allan Collins, however in it, he describes the affinity he has with the location in which he has based the story …


      I am also aware that murder / mysteries are general not part of your preferred reading schedule, however ‘Girl Most Likely’ has some great character based chapters and a few of those ‘human’ moments, which left me smiling.

      I guess I am just trying to say that overall, this was a face-paced, easy-reading, page-turner, which I am almost certain you would enjoy!

      Thanks for stopping by and taking the time to comment. Happy Reading 🙂

  • This one made my wish list following your earlier posts. I’m fascinated by both the story and the author’s diverse credentials, so I feel sure it will eventually make its way to my TBR pile.

    As for acknowledgments… I always read them. (along with introductions, prefaces, prologues, end notes, etc.) I do skim all the “thank yous”, but have learned important tidbits can often be found in these extras.

    • Hi Kelly,

      Final reviews and ratings for this one have been a little mixed, but from my own personal perspective, although not an earth-shattering storyline, it was relevant, intriguing to watch as everyone sought to cover their own tracks and indiscretions, and I enjoyed the extracts where the dialogue switched to the third person, making me more a part of the action!

      Actually, now you have put it into perspective, I am probably not as bad at reading the acknowledgements as I had thought. It is more the fact that I too, skim over all the ‘Thank yous’, of which there are often many!

      Like yourself, I always read the prologues, end notes etc., as I never know what I might be missing out on!

      Thank you for taking the time to comment.

      We are in for another storm system this weekend, so a very wet and windy day ahead. I hope that your own weekend is more calm and peaceful 🙂

  • It sounds like a good one overall, hopefully the other ones in the series provide a little bit more background and motive for some of the characters actions. I don’t like loose ends either while reading. And I tend to read the acknowledgements, out of sheer curiosity. Great review as always!

    • Hi Naida,

      Any ‘loose ends’ in this book certainly didn’t detract from the storyline, which I am pleased to say, had a very definite beginning, middle and end. It just would have been nice to have had some of the extraneous narrative put into some context.

      A lot of the ebooks and ARC copies, don’t always include the acknowledgements, however I shall now be allowing plenty of extra time to browse for them whenever possible, just to see if there are any extra snippets of information I can include in a post, or one of the memes I regularly attend!

      Thanks for the interesting contribution to the discussion, I always appreciate your comments 🙂

Written by Yvonne