• Search
  • Lost Password?
Sharing our love for authors, and the stories they are inspired to tell.

The Lip
by Charlie Carroll

The opportunity to read this debut novel, was one of those ‘right time, right place’ Netgalley moments, when publisher Two Roads Books released some ‘Read Now’ copies, so my thanks to all concerned.

Cover Image of the book 'The Lip' by author Charlie Carroll


Cover Image of the book 'The Lip' by author Charlie CarrollAway from the hotels and holiday lets, there is an unseen side of Cornwall, where the shifting uncertainties of the future breed resentment and mistrust.

Melody Janie is hidden.

She lives alone in a caravan in Bones Break: a small cliff-top on Cornwall’s north coast.

She spends her time roaming her territory, spying on passing tourists and ramblers, and remembering. She sees everything and yet remains unseen.

However, when a stranger enters her life, she is forced to confront not only him but the terrible tragedies of her past.

The Lip is a novel about childhood, isolation and mental health, told in the unique and unforgettable voice of Melody Janie.

Cover Image of the book 'The Lip' by author Charlie Carroll


Image of author Charlie CarrollCharlie Carroll is the author of three non-fiction books: The Friendship Highway (2014), No Fixed Abode (2013) and On the Edge (2010).

He has twice won the K Blundell Trust Award for ‘writers under 40 who aim to raise social awareness with their writing’.

He wrote the voice-over for the TV series Transamazonica (2017), and is one of the Kindness of Strangers storytellers.

The Lip is his debut novel.

He lives in Cornwall.

Keep up to date with all Charlie’s latest news at his website

Follow Charlie on Twitter

Cover Image of the book 'The Lip' by author Charlie Carroll


“If the cold made an impression on her, she did not show it. Nor the prospect of the drop. The tide was at its lowest. No water awaited her down there, only black sand”

Cover Image of the book 'The Lip' by author Charlie Carroll


“Naming something gives it form and existence, makes it memorable”


“To have a nickname you need to be either very popular or very unpopular, and I was neither. I seemed to pass through school largely unnoticed”


“Necessary evil is still evil”


“Mum was no help, had not been since the day Dad died. It was like she was made of sand and a wave had washed over her”


“A good night to be beside water that is still rather than rough, with reflections that are glassy and unbroken, where the moon will swell up from the black water like a submerged torch”


“Just because you can’t feel or see someone, it doesn’t mean you should stop thinking about them”


“Fear can drive you to terrible places”


“My land is leaving me. Like everything else”

Cover Image of the book 'The Lip' by author Charlie Carroll


“Let them visit, don’t let them stay”

Warning! Tissues will be required before you get to the end of this one!

That wistful cover art was the first thing which caught my eye, followed by the unique premise which held so much promise, written by a new to me author with such an intriguing biography – who could resist!

An exquisitely balanced, slow-burning, often lugubrious storyline, unfolded from the very first page and held me enthralled and trapped in its web of fragility until the very last word, when I emerged battered, bruised and almost broken, by Melody’s sad journey and final earth-shattering revelation, which in all honesty I never saw coming, even though I might have been one of the few who didn’t!

As this story featured few characters and covered such a small physical footprint, some fluently written, well structured, short chapters, which appeared almost seamless, kept everything focussed, very fluid and more importantly gave me those much needed short breathing spaces before continuing on my journey, without ever becoming disjointed or ‘clunky’. To expand further on the already cohesive premise, would be divulging far too many spoilers, so you really need to watch this immersive storyline unfold and play-out for yourself.

Multi layered, powerfully original in its concept, with an almost lyrical simplicity, yet hauntingly raw passion in its writing, The Lip offers a perceptive, poignant and beautifully nuanced journey, which explores the constantly changing frailty of the human mind; the destructive consequences of loneliness and isolation; the promise, power and redemptive qualities of family and friendship; tempered by the faint glimmer of recovery and hope for the future. This is a story about people clinging onto the edge with their fingertips, while all around them their world falls away.

A small cast of multi-faceted, wonderfully well drawn and defined characters, completely owned this storyline, with every word spoken and every action taken, being executed with careful consideration, an almost brutal yet naive honesty, and clear often compassionless thought for the consequences. Not easy to connect with or relate to, all searching for their own individual sense of belonging, totally unreliable, volatile and often manipulative, there is nonetheless a vulnerability and genuine authenticity about them, which makes them addictive and beguiling.

Narrated exclusively in the first person, by Melody Janie herself, who is often given to extremes of emotion and paranoia, her strength of passion and determination belie her perceived fragility of thought and reasoning. Protecting ‘her’ little corner of Cornwall from the Emmets (I have always used the word Grockle to mean the same thing), whilst waiting for her mother to return home, has been her all-consuming mission. The arrival of a stranger causes Melody extreme angst and distress, especially when she hears some disturbing information about the unwanted new guest to the area. Their forced relationship forms a pivotal part of the storyline and as their individual experiences are shared, they are each driven to the edge of both their physical and mental capacity to cope. They are destined to hurt one another, almost to the brink of destruction, before truth and honesty pull them back from the precipice and sow the seeds of new beginnings.

So powerful and intuitively skilled in the imagery of words and the depth, range and dimension they can add to a story, author Charlie Carroll has made the landscape of this small area of ‘off the beaten track’ Cornish coastline and its nearby villages, characters in their own right. Uncompromisingly, yet sympathetically and empathetically documented, the narrative delves deep into the consequences of social injustices caused by the current trend of ‘second home’ culture, which has all but destroyed the rural economy and home owning potential for the indigenous residents of the local  community. As if to pour scorn on an already smouldering cauldron, severe storms causing coastal erosion and cliff landslips threaten Melody’s home and indeed her very life, although the purging and reshaping of the landscape acts as a catalyst for her reawakening and the small steps forward she must take, if she is to escape the long shadows caused by her mother’s ill health.

All the many reasons for which I read, were thrown out of the window, with the exception of ’emotion’, which oozed from the pages in copious quantities, threatening to overwhelm me at any moment. Reading this book definitely took me on a unique, personal and definitely not always comfortable journey, so I urge you to check out The Lip for yourself and see where your journey leads you!

Image of author Charlie Carroll

A complimentary kindle download of this book, for review purposes, was made available by the publisher, and supplied by NetGalley

Any thoughts or comments are my own personal opinion and I am in no way being monetarily compensated for this, or any other article which promotes this book or its author.

I personally do not agree with ‘rating’ a book, as the overall experience is all a matter of personal taste, which varies from reader to reader. However some review sites do demand a rating value, so when this review is posted to such a site, it will attract a well deserved 5 out of 5 stars!


Written by

I can’t remember a time, even as a child, when I haven’t been passionate about books and reading.
I began blogging, when I realised just how many other people out there shared my passion for the written word and I have been continually amazed at the wealth of books that are available and the amount of great new friends I have made, from literally 'The Four Corners Of The World'.

View all articles
Leave a Reply to Yvonne Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    • The cover is so simple, yet so eye-catching, isn’t it? It also really ‘does what it says on the tin’ and is a genuine reflection of the storyline.

      Recently, I seem to have read lots of books where mental health is a pivotal part of the storyline, but this is definitely one of the best!

      It is hauntingly sad and poignant, with an added twist that I never saw coming!

      Thanks for stopping by, I hope that all is well with you and stay safe 🙂

    • Everyone seems to find the cover particularly appealing and it really does encapsulate the storyline so well!

      There are a couple of clever twists in the plot, but this one is essentially all about the characters.

      One I think you might really enjoy! 🙂

  • It sounds like a fascinating read. I went on a caravanning trip in Cornwall, on a cliff, and it was so amazing. I should keep this book in mind if (well, when) I’m going back to Cornwall.

    • I have to confess that I have never had a holiday in a caravan, even as a child. I can’t think of a worse way to spend a week, or even worse, two weeks, of my life. I really would rather stay at home!!

      I don’t think you would want to pitch your caravan anywhere near this particular piece of clifftop though – far too dangerous!

      It really is a well written and structured storyline, despite, or maybe because of, the obvious turmoil of Melody Janie’s mind.

      Thanks for stopping by and I hope that the mask wearing gets a bit better this weekend for you! 🙂

  • This one sounds fascination, Yvonne. I agree… the cover captured my attention right off the bat. I’ll add it to my wishlist for now. 😉

    • This storyline is probably one which I wouldn’t have chosen for myself, however it was one of those surprise reads which was totally immersive and really grabbed my attention right up to the end.

      Melody Janie is definitely a troubled soul, with her physical loneliness and frail mind both colluding against her, as she fights to save her safe little corner of Cornwall.

      If this one ever comes up on offer anywhere, I think you would really appreciate the writing style of this author 🙂

  • I think the cover stands out because it looks like an artist created it; it doesn’t seem like one of the “canned” ones that are pretty common these days–cost-cutting? That’s my guess. I was fascinated by the title. It had a couple of possible meanings, but seeing the cover cleared up that ambiguity. Thanks for telling us about this one.

    • I know what you mean about “canned” cover images, some of them are pretty dreadful and don’t match the title or premise at all. It’s even worse when character images are visually out of sync with the timeframe of the storyline.

      With coastal erosion being what it is, “The Lip” is definitely not somewhere you would want to unhitch your caravan – and therein lies a very significant ‘spoiler’!

      Thanks for stopping by and I hope that all is well with you 🙂

  • I saw you’d reviewed this on Twitter, planned to come and read it and then promptly forgot all about it. Apologies. I knew about the Cornish connection with this one but for some reason was convinced it was non-fiction. I’ve no idea why, possibly the cover. Anyway, I’ll keep an eye for this at the library as it feels like something I ought to read.

    • The author has previously written non-fiction, with this being his debut novel, so perhaps that’s what you were thinking of.

      I think that the Cornish connection is quite relevant to this storyline, although probably only in Melody Janie’s mind, as I think she would have developed similar proprietary feelings, no matter where she lived.

      The author writes about a fragile state of mind with such depth of feeling and ‘caring’, that although sad and poignant, it really was a joy to read, especially as it is not the kind of storyline I would probably look twice at on the shelves of the bookshop or library.

      Thanks for taking the time to comment, I really appreciate it! 🙂

Written by Yvonne